I Tried Reese Witherspoon’s “Favorite” Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

Trending 3 weeks ago

We independently prime these products—if you bargain from 1 of our links, we whitethorn gain a commission. All prices were meticulous astatine nan clip of publishing.

Reese Witherspoon's Pumpkin Cookies connected parchment

Credit: Kiersten Hickman

In my opinion, autumn is simply a clip for 3 very circumstantial things: reference spooky books, drinking frothy cups of coffee, and baking each nan pumpkin-flavored baked goods. So you tin only ideate really invested I was erstwhile Reese Witherspoon not only announced a spooky book for her October book nine prime this year, but besides her favourite look for pumpkin cocoa spot cookies — pinch a cup of java successful hand! It’s each of my autumn dreams coming to life successful 1 Instagram post. 

While Reese is known for having a fewer delightful recipes of her ain — including her grandmother’s divine Southern sour pick cake — this look really isn’t 1 she made up. In nan caption of her Instagram station wherever she waxes astir these cookies, she says that this look was developed by Chef Sandra. Nevertheless, I couldn’t thief but cook up a batch myself, and fto maine show you — they are perfectly worthy being diligent for.

How to Make Reese Witherspoon’s Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

Melt 1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted food successful a medium-sized microwave-safe bowl. Let nan food cool somewhat while you stitchery nan remainder of your ingredients.

In different mini bowl, whisk together 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour, 1/4 spoon of salt, 1/4 spoon baking powder, 1/4 spoon baking soda, 1 spoon pumpkin herb seasoning, and 1 1/2 teaspoons cinnamon. 

In nan vessel pinch nan melted butter, whisk successful 1/4 cup ray brownish sugar, 1/4 cup acheronian brownish sugar, and 1/4 cup granulated sugar. Once incorporated, whisk successful 1 spoon vanilla extract and 6 tablespoons caller pumpkin purée (be judge to strain it first!) until combined.

Sprinkle nan barren ingredients into nan vessel of bedewed ingredients, past whisk until smooth. Once finished, fold successful 1 cup of semi-sweet cocoa chips.

Cover nan vessel pinch integrative wrap aliases a reusable screen and spot nan cooky mixed successful nan fridge for astatine slightest 30 minutes. You could fto it property moreover longer; according to Reese, nan mixed tin enactment prepped successful nan fridge for up to 3 days.

When it’s clip to bake, preheat nan oven to 350°F. Line a baking expanse (you mightiness request two, actually) pinch parchment paper. With cleanable hands, scoop 1 tablespoonful of mixed and rotation it into a ball. Place nan cooky mixed shot connected nan baking expanse and property down slightly. Be judge to springiness nan cookies capable abstraction — astatine slightest 2 inches apart.

Bake nan cookies successful nan oven for 11 to 12 minutes. They will look soft, but baked through. Let nan cookies remainder for 10 minutes connected nan baking expanse earlier removing them to a cooling rack. Reese recommends letting them cool wholly earlier devouring; she says they’re amended that way!

I’m a large instrumentality of a soft, chewy cookie, truthful these pumpkin cocoa spot cookies get an A+ successful my book. They’re soft and moist, but they don’t autumn apart, and each wound feels for illustration I’m eating a pumpkin muffin alternatively than a cookie. So technically, they tin beryllium considered meal pinch that cup of java successful my head. (Win, win.)

These cookies besides person a bully shape. Sometimes I consciousness for illustration homemade cookies don’t get that cleanable round, but these each person a azygous style that make them worthy to station connected Instagram. They’re besides not flat; they’re nicely domed astatine nan apical and person that perfect crinkly edge. 

What’s more, I’m a large instrumentality of really these cookies don’t sensation overly sweet. Sure, there’s rather a spot of sweetener successful them, but you really get much of nan sweeteners from nan cocoa chips than nan cooky itself. If you’re for illustration maine and you for illustration a dessert that isn’t excessively cloying, you tin ever skip nan cocoa chips and conscionable make nan pumpkin cookies without. Again, they’ll brace awesome pinch a cup of coffee. Or moreover a chai latte!

Three Tips for Making Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Don’t person caller pumpkin? Use canned. Reese’s look technically calls for pumpkin purée that has been strained, which is emblematic if you decided to make fresh pumpkin purée from scratch. But for illustration Reese successful nan video, we’re going to skip that laborious measurement and scope for our favourite canned pumpkin. No straining necessary!
  • The longer nan mixed ages, nan better. It whitethorn sound strange, but ripening cooky dough (also known arsenic “aging”) earlier baking it really allows for an moreover chewier, tastier cookie. That’s because nan fats wrong nan cooky — successful this case, it’s nan food — are chilled. When you cook nan cooky pinch acold fat, it gives it a wholly different texture. Plus, aging nan mixed gives nan flour clip to soak up nan liquids successful nan cookie, giving it clip to “hydrate” truthful your cooky isn’t barren and crumbly but soft and ooey-gooey. This look recommends waiting astatine slightest 30 minutes, but I gave nan cookies 3 hours earlier baking. 
  • Store them up to a week: While I highly uncertainty you’ll person immoderate leftovers if you service these cookies astatine Thanksgiving, if you do person immoderate left, nan champion point is to shop them astatine room somesthesia successful an airtight container. The sooner you eat them nan better, but you tin support them for up to a week. Don’t want your cookies to get hard? Store them pinch a portion of bread. Yes, really!