My Mom's Legendary Potato Stuffing Is Worth Fighting Over

Trending 3 weeks ago

Pennsylvania Dutch Potato Filling Recipe

Mashed potatoes meet stuffing successful this caller classical Thanksgiving broadside dish.

Serves8 to 10

Prep20 minutes

Cook1 hr 30 minutes

We independently prime these products—if you bargain from 1 of our links, we whitethorn gain a commission. All prices were meticulous astatine nan clip of publishing.

Potato stuffing successful a casserole baking crockery pinch a serving spoon.

Credit: Photo: Ryan Liebe; Food Styling: Rachel Perlmutter

Imagine a cozy casserole that has nan creamy texture of mashed potatoes pinch nan crisp and chewy bites of stuffing. Well, you don’t person to ideate it immoderate longer! Meet: my mom’s Pennsylvania Dutch murphy filling. It’s a literal mash-up of mashed potatoes and stuffing, each successful 1 dish. Don’t get maine incorrect — my dad’s mashed potatoes are arsenic fluffy arsenic a cloud, but I can’t defy this crockery astatine Thanksgiving. This year, you won’t deliberation doubly astir putting much than conscionable 1 type of murphy crockery connected nan table.

Credit: Photo: Ryan Liebe; Food Styling: Rachel Perlmutter

Ingredients successful Potato Filling

  • Russet potatoes: Serve arsenic nan guidelines for nan mashed potatoes.
  • Potato bread: My mom uses murphy breadstuff for its rich, buttery spirit and fluffy texture. 
  • Aromatics: Onion, celery, and ail shape nan main spirit base. 
  • Fresh herbs: My mom doesn’t ever usage sage and thyme, but I for illustration nan acquainted and cozy vacation spirit they bring to nan dish. 
  • Poultry seasoning: My mom insists connected utilizing this seasoning. Its main ingredients are dried sage, thyme, rosemary, marjoram, nutmeg, and bulb powder. Don’t skip it — it adds a bully herby spirit to nan dish.
  • Chicken broth: My mom opts for chickenhearted broth to adhd an almost gravy-like spirit to nan dish.
  • Unsalted butter: Let nan food beryllium astatine room somesthesia while you boil nan potatoes. It’ll melt faster erstwhile mixed pinch nan mashed potatoes.
  • Milk: Use full beverage for a richer flavor.
  • Eggs: Help moisten nan dried breadstuff cubes and support nan breadstuff fluffy arsenic it bakes.

If You’re Making Potato Filling, a Few Tips

  • Start pinch a half cup of broth. I telephone for adding a 1/2 cup of chickenhearted broth to nan breadstuff cubes, which should beryllium conscionable moistened, not soggy. You tin adhd up to an other 1/4 cup if needed. It’s OK if immoderate barren spots stay — conscionable make judge that nan breadstuff doesn’t break apart. 
  • Make judge nan potatoes aren’t wholly mashed. Mash only a fewer times to guarantee that pieces of murphy remain, and nan texture is not excessively smooth.

Mashed potatoes meet stuffing successful this caller classical Thanksgiving broadside dish.


  • 7 tablespoons

    unsalted butter, divided

  • 1 cup

    whole milk

  • 2

    large eggs

  • About 10 ounces murphy sandwich breadstuff (8 to 9 slices, astir 1/2 loaf)

  • 3 pounds

    russet potatoes

  • 2 tablespoons

    kosher salt, divided

  • 1

    medium yellowish onion

  • 2

    large stalks celery

  • 3

    cloves garlic

  • 5

    sprigs caller parsley

  • 8

    large aliases 12 mean caller sage leaves

  • 2

    sprigs caller thyme

  • 1 teaspoon

    freshly crushed achromatic pepper, divided

  • 2/3 cup

    plus 1 tablespoonful low-sodium chickenhearted broth, divided, positive much arsenic needed

  • 1/2 teaspoon

    salt-free poultry seasoning

  1. Place 4 tablespoons of nan unsalted food and 1 cup full beverage connected nan counter. Place 1 tablespoonful of nan unsalted food successful a 9x13-inch aliases different 3-quart baking dish. Place 2 ample eggs successful a ample bowl. Let everything beryllium astatine room somesthesia while you hole nan remaining ingredients.

  2. Arrange a rack successful nan mediate of nan oven and power nan oven to 300°F. Meanwhile, trim 10 ounces murphy sandwich breadstuff into 1/2-inch cubes (about 8 cups). Place connected a rimmed baking expanse and dispersed retired into an moreover layer.

  3. Bake until dried and ray golden-brown, astir 20 minutes. Meanwhile, hole nan potatoes.

  4. Peel 3 pounds russet potatoes. Cut into 1-inch cubes and spot successful a ample pot. Add 1 tablespoonful of nan kosher brackish and adhd capable cool h2o to screen nan potatoes by astir 1-inch. Bring to a boil complete medium-high heat. Reduce nan power arsenic needed to support a simmer and navigator until nan potatoes are fork-tender, 5 to 7 minutes.

  5. While nan potatoes are cooking, dice 1 mean yellowish bulb (about 1 1/2 cups) and 2 ample celery stalks (about 1 cup). Mince 3 ail cloves. Pick nan leaves from 5 caller parsley sprigs and finely chop until you person 2 tablespoons. Finely chop 8 ample aliases 12 mean sage leaves until you person 1 tablespoon. Pick nan leaves from 2 caller thyme sprigs and finely chop until you person 1 tablespoon.

  6. When nan breadstuff is ready, region from nan oven and group speech to cool. Increase nan oven somesthesia to 375ºF.

  7. When potatoes are ready, drain and return to nan pot. Add nan 4 tablespoons softened butter. Let beryllium for astir 1 infinitesimal to afloat melt nan butter. Mash 8 to 10 times pinch a murphy masher aliases fork, leaving nan potatoes chunky. Add nan milk, 1 1/2 teaspoons of nan kosher salt, and 1/2 spoon of nan achromatic pepper. Stir to combine.

  8. Melt 1 tablespoonful of nan unsalted food successful a ample frying cookware complete medium-high heat. Add 1 tablespoonful of nan low-sodium chickenhearted broth, nan onions, and celery. Sauté until softened and translucent, 5 to 7 minutes. Add nan ail and sauté until fragrant, astir 30 seconds. Add nan parsley, sage, and thyme. Sauté until fragrant, astir 30 seconds. Transfer nan bulb substance to nan cookware of mashed potatoes.

  9. Add nan remaining 2/3 cup chickenhearted broth, 1/2 spoon poultry seasoning, remaining 1 1/2 teaspoons kosher salt, and remaining 1/2 spoon achromatic capsicum to nan vessel of eggs and whisk to combine. Add nan breadstuff cubes and mildly fold together until nan breadstuff cubes are conscionable moistened (it’s OK if a fewer spots are still somewhat dry). If nan breadstuff is excessively dry, operation successful much broth a tablespoonful astatine a clip arsenic needed.

  10. Transfer nan breadstuff to nan cookware of mashed potatoes. Gently fold to combine, being observant not to break up nan breadstuff cubes.

  11. Use your fingers aliases a brushwood to overgarment nan baking crockery pinch nan now-softened butter. Transfer nan breadstuff substance to nan baking crockery and dispersed into an moreover layer. Cut nan remaining 1 tablespoonful unsalted food into bladed slices and scatter complete nan apical of nan stuffing.

  12. Bake until nan apical is ray aureate and nan breadstuff cubes that are poking retired are crisp to nan touch, astir 45 minutes. Let cool for 10 minutes earlier serving.

Recipe Notes

Substitutions: 8 cups Martin’s Potato Bread cubes tin beryllium substituted for nan sandwich breadstuff — nary request to barren retired successful nan oven.

Storage: Refrigerate leftovers successful an airtight instrumentality for up to 4 days.